It appeared repulsive, the only captivating part of the film i thought was the powerful ending of her performance as the black swan. So the reason why ninas story plays out how it does is because black swan is an extreme depiction of the welldocumented psychological issues ballerinas face. Basicly, feeling betrayed because the prince has chosen the black swan, the white swan kills herself. Aug 25, 2012 decoding symbols in black swan perfection is not just about control, but also letting go. I have to state that theres another explanation to the film wich i also find very aproppiate. Black swan was one of the filmcasts favorite films of the year. Analyzing the motherdaughter relationship black swan poignantly illustrates ninas struggle to tap into her own passion and to forge an identity separate from her mothers, both of which are necessary to succeed as a ballerina as well as in life. Jan 27, 2011 the black swan and psychological illness. Darren aronofskys black swan is a fullbore melodrama, told with passionate intensity, gloriously and darkly absurd. With this understanding of the external context, we can now dive into explaining what happened in the movie. In accordance with the story of the ballet, it is the evil twin who takes. But after watching the film, one of the things i was left wondering was. Dec 01, 2016 the real meaning behind these confusing movie endings. Black swan is a 2010 american psychological horror film directed by darren aronofsky.
The first fifteen minutes of this black swan has been explained to the audience from the main choreographer to the women, unfortunately i couldnt find a video on youtube but if you have seen the film the scene i am referring to would be familiar. The plot revolves around a production of tchaikovskys swan lake ballet by the prestigious new york city ballet company. The real meaning behind these confusing movie endings. I watched a couple days after whiplash because i guess i was into super tense films about obsessed artists this week, and i thoroughly enjoyed both though black swan was definitely much more uncomfortable to watch that hangnail scene ugh. Surely its time to go back to staging swan lake as it used to be before the 1940s, with no black swan at all, but with the antiheroine odile dressed in strong colors, as a woman of the world.
Black swan ending, explained meaning, plot, theory. Swan lake black swan 2010 movie plot ending explained i personally think nina died but natalie portman said herself that she thinks nina lives and finally becomes a woman. In the ending of the gift, gordo reveals his final gift to simon and robyn. Black swan is ionospherically over the top, and some of its effects are overdone, but it is richly, sensually enjoyable and there is such fascination in. Black swan is a dense and layered film, with so much to focus on. First, it introduces and promises a surreal tone to the film. Along with a detailed plot analysis and explanation of the ending of the film black swan well also go through the details of the original ballet swan lake.
Black swan was presented in a sneak screening at the telluride film festival on september 5, 2010. Movie plot ending explained when i first saw darren aronofskys film black swan, natalie portmans acting shined, and the movie was terrific. Apr 20, 2017 black swan is a dense and layered film, with so much to focus on. And third, after it happens everyone comes up with some explanation for it that makes it seem like it actually wasnt random and could have been predicted. Darren aronofsky wanted joaquin phoenix for his batman movie. We unpack the meaning of the final scenes of black swan 2010. The ending is deliberately somewhat ambiguous, because a lot of the movie deals with issues about realitynonreality. The goldenglobe nominated film takes viewers deep into a ballerinas descent into madness in a frightening portrait of psychosis that. Black swan deconstructed, films many faces the new. Mindjob movie braids insanity explained taylor holmes inc. She killed her opponent as black swan, then as a white swan she is scared and feels regret. Blacks next mission is choi geunho, who he shoots pointblank in the head. Assuming the final scene of black swan is not a hallucination, nina injured herself some significant time earlier in her dressing room and danced two entire sections as the black, and then the whi.
Mar 22, 2019 the ending to jordan peeles latest horror film is bold, ambitious, and a little tricky to understand. Second, it aligns the story of the movie with the story of swan lake, meaning we should look at the movie. The film begins with a prestigious ballet company in new york city preparing for a production of swan lake. Jun 09, 2016 screenprism is the hub for film and tv analysis. This was my first film visual analysis, written for my visual communication class under the late ms.
Later, black swan dives off the cliff, hoping that haram will be happy once her memories of him are erased. Portman explained being part of black swan, im trying to find roles that demand more adulthood from me. The movie is about a ballet dancer, nina, that wishes to achieve perfection in order to have the grand role of the swan queen in the prestigious swan. For example, instead of the swan maidens, we have the addition of sidekicks puffin the puffin, speed the tortoise, and jeanbob the frog. A truly exciting, beautiful and mesmerising movie, it was directed by darren aronofsky and starring natalie portman, vincent cassel, mila kunis and winona ryder. Films like black swan and jacobs ladder were brilliant at depicting a slow descent into madness or conditions like ptsd, and the babadook stands among them as an entry into how well horror can be used as a backdrop for deeper psychological issues.
In black swan, when nina visits the previous main dancer, beth, in hospital, she stabs her face with the nail file, but then nina sees herself in her. The hidden meaning in black swan earthling cinema youtube. Movie explained in short plot explanation the story of a romantic encounter between a spy james and a scientist danielle, which displays reasonable chemistry between the characters, is concluded a year later with him being held hostage and her heading out on. An artistic masterpiece, black swan is a 2010 movie of the psychological thriller genre. Jan 20, 2011 black swan is ionospherically over the top, and some of its effects are overdone, but it is richly, sensually enjoyable and there is such fascination in seeing portman surrender to the madness and. Darren aronofskys black swan 2010 focuses on two characters from swan lakethe princess odette, sometimes called the white swan, and her evil duplicate, the witch odile the black swan, and takes its inspiration from the ballets story, although it does not literally follow it.
Producer darren aronofsky admits that the idea for the story came from his interest in understudies and the notion of being haunted by a double, as in the double. The director of the company, thomas leroy vincent cassel, is determined to. There are three characteristics that define a black swan. Black swan screened in competition and is the third consecutive film directed by aronofsky to premiere at the festival, following the fountain and the wrestler. Black swan is about a ballet dancer who wins the lead role of the swan queen that requires to dance as both the sweet white and evil black swans. Jun 09, 2018 what if an alien in the future stumbled upon darren aronofskys black swan. A petersburg poem 1946, a novella by russian author fyodor dostoyevsky 18211881. Can someone tell me what really happened in black swan. This occurred to me about halfway through the movie and i seriously thought was going to be revealed by the end, but it never was. It is unclear whether or not robyns baby is gordos or simons, but gordo gives the hint, its all in the eyes, you see. The swan princess 1994 is a nest entertainment film based on the swan lake story. What does nina sayers say at the end of black swan. Decoding symbols in black swan the film experience. Feb 10, 2011 surely its time to go back to staging swan lake as it used to be before the 1940s, with no black swan at all, but with the antiheroine odile dressed in strong colors, as a woman of the world.
Welcome to earthling cinema, where we examine the last remaining artifacts of. In the ending credits of the film, every actor is credited not just with their role in the film, but also their counterparts in swan lake itself. A black swan is an event or occurrence that deviates beyond what is normally expected of a situation and is extremely difficult to predict. Mar 21, 2019 sometimes we trip into movies that catch you completely off guard. Actually after watching the movie many times and watching explaining videos it just pretty clear to me now that the death scene is that nina killed. Black swan deconstructed, films many faces the new york. While natalie portman gets to be the swan queen, mila kunis is the one credited with the black swan. It stays fairly close to the original story, but does contain many differences.
This is basically the white swan and black swan respectively. Movie explained in short plot explanation the story of a romantic encounter between a spy james and a scientist danielle, which displays reasonable chemistry between the characters, is concluded a year later with him being held hostage and her heading out on a risky deepsea excursion. Even though the film begins with a dream which is important to keep in mind at all times. As the two young dancers expand their rivalry into a twisted friendship, nina begins to get more in touch with. Ninas disordered relationship with her roommate mother erica, played by barbara hershey, sets the stage for ninas psychological breakdown. Sign up to our email newsletter for updates on new videos, fun film. If you have a question please ask below and i will get back to you as soon as possible. Black swan is based on a screenplay cowritten by screenwriters mark heyman, andres heinz, and john mclaughlin. She dances as the white swan in the swan lake ballet, and the next day discovers.
After this scene, she is able to perform the black swan because she has become the sexualized, noholdsbarred person that she and thomas wanted her to be. We want to celebrate our different opinions, and celebrate yours as well. Black swan is an interesting film for many reasons, not the least of which is that this story is told through the eyes of an unreliable narrator. For a more concrete answer, i suggest that because ninas life mirrors the swan lake story ie. Arbeitskorper, lustkorper darren arnofskys black swan.
Welcome to earthling cinema, where we examine the last remaining artifacts of a onceproud culture and try to understand. Watching it again, something triggered in my mind to assemble some pieces of a puzzle. Black swan explained the central theme is around two character types a gentle, innocent person. This approach probably works better in a horror film than in the other genres the director has attacked, and while, make no mistake, black swan is never going to end up on the shelves next to black sunday, the moments of greatest impact in the movie are almost exclusively the most classically horrific. Even if the timeline itself is also a hallucination, she at least danced the final vigorous scene, so the injury cant have been that serious. Jan 21, 2011 could somebody explain the black swan to me. What if an alien in the future stumbled upon darren aronofskys black swan. Christopher nolans film left audiences minds spinning as much as the top in the final shot. Currently, we are building the largest digital library of film and television inquiry and related content by producing original articles, curating content from other esteemed sources and facilitating user generated comment and discussion. But the nuances missed me entirely because i had no clue about the swan lake ballet which they are rehearsing for in the film. The idea of a doppelganger also extends to the end of the film, providing plot twists and psychological tension. Too many film sites cater to the same kind of audience, with one overwhelming voice in the writing, but what we treasure at alternate ending is diversity.
There is a play called black swan, where there is an innocent white swan who falls in love with the prince and a seductive black swan who seduces the prince first. Whats the messagemeaning behind black swan the movie. What really happened at the end of that confusing movie you just saw. The black swan movie is a kind of captivating work that will give you a clear and better understanding about a psychotic illness. Swan lake requires a dancer who can play both the white swan with innocence and grace, and the black swan, who represents guile and sensuality.
In order to provide a black swan movie explanation, its important to first provide a summary of the plot. If you want additional information regarding the psychological disorder that are presented in the black swan movie, just browse the internet or watch the black swan movie of natalie portman. Dec 15, 2017 black tosses the live wires into the pool, electrocuting missingfinger. First of all id like to say that i absolutely loved this film. Towards the end when nina kills lily she really just stabbed herself with the glass, which was basically her final release and allowed her to fully become the black swan. Assuming the final scene of black swan is not a hallucination, nina injured herself some significant time earlier in her dressing room and danced two entire sections as the black, and then the white, swan, which included a costume change. Black swan follows the story of nina portman, a ballerina in a new york city ballet company whose life, like all those in her profession, is completely consumed with dance.